Latest blog post: How the comic is made (2025-12-26)

Author's comment:

Something-something, don't trust all your decisions to an algorithm.



Add Comment

* Required information
30000
Powered by Commentics

Comments (4)

Avatar
Senior

So in the general, unfiltered scan there was an anomolous reading that could be disregarded as signal noise, but with an unfiltered detail scan, narrowed on the anomolous area what first appears to be signal noise shows clearly to be unnatural.

Avatar
Visitor

That's an eternal conundrum with filters and filter configuration, to decide what is some sort of anomaly/glitch/sensor specific behaviour, and what is a real thing, that shouldn't be filtered out.

Even more interesting, when computers are involved, and you have to trust them that the filtering programs are not subverted. (and the "fun" thing is, pretty much every modern measuring equipment has some computers in it, or multiple ...).

Avatar
Senior

And then an intelligent adversary can go and deliberately modify the signals telegraphing his presence so as to look (more) like genuine noise, too.

(Spread spectrum, anyone?)

Avatar
Senior

Here's my best guess at a translation from the last panel:

-

line-1:

from wiki cyrillic: эи, оснал {human} ро нехтнарха нуе кахсу {!}

from wiki latin: zi, osnal {human} ro nehtnarha nue kahsu {!}

google translate: Hey, Osnal {human} the price is not cheap {!}

from wiki dictionary: ?, anecdote {human} 'particle "property"' exploration 'particle "little"' thing {!}

What I think: "Hey, the human found a ting!"

-

Line-2:

from wiki cyrillic: оснанха нуе ках.

from wiki latin: osnanha nue kah

google translate: osnanha no problem

from wiki dictionary: role 'particle "little"' 'creature, it'

What I think: "There's a little guy."

-

The ipad highlights the "center problem"

from wiki latin: hfrao raks

from wiki dictionary: center problem

Avatar
Regular

Oh well, reason numero 4 so "Discovering by chance that your allies' computer systems have been compromised by a fourth-party". Oops.

So, they are astronomers, and therefore certainly trained in confidentiality procedures, so we can hoped for a certain amount of discretion on their part. But all of this is probably too big to keep the complet secret. Quite a kick in the anthill today.

Avatar
Senior

Or now comes the hard part : the info is confidential..."NoForn"..

So I take it the Raharr will now have to space their new Terran friends

"Its the hardest thing I ever had to doooo.. Mew hew hew...."

(Edited)
Avatar
Senior

Well... This isn't a Raharran military vessel, its civilian, so all the Raharr and Alliance members on board probably aren't cleared for knowledge about the Ghosts either. Heck, even among the military vessels it might only be the highest commander and his 2IC who are cleared together with Commander Zane and Quantum to know.

Avatar
Regular

So, Zane could order total secrecy and confidentiality from his civilians, but given the circumstances and the serious implications of this discovery, the situation would be too unstable and the secret would come out sooner or later. No, it seem more likly that Zane have probably enough authority and respect to ask discretion and for silence in waiting for an official statement to make soon later.

Else, on a almost unrelated topic: I'm wonder if Quantum can read the raw data and see the anomaly like the squishy meatbags... do you imagine the existencial crisis that they absolutely cannot see the anomaly?

Avatar
Senior

To be fair, this doesn't inform anyone of the Ghosts. The Raharr are aware of "The Ancients" and other life forms in the galaxy at large. This flight crew could easily believe they've found something else left behind by "The Ancients" or simply another alien species that found Earth, didn't make contact but left something behind to monitor or perform another function.

The greater secret of the "Ghosts" as an elusive, advanced alien species which abducts and experiments on other races can remain knowledge to the highest officers/officials. But it wouldn't surprise me if a big find like this may spark the next level of personnel being informed of the Ghosts.

Avatar
Visitor

"lse, on a almost unrelated topic: I'm wonder if Quantum can read the raw data and see the anomaly like the squishy meatbags... do you imagine the existencial crisis that they absolutely cannot see the anomaly?"

Depends on whether they have their own routines to process the data, and if they have been subverted too, or not ... An interesting thing to ponder on by anyone involved ...

Avatar
New

having met a fair number of astronomers (it's a big hobby for my father, who even did some legit research into variable stars using his backyard set up for awhile. and he made a number of connections through conferences and such) i'm not surprised they wanted to look at the raw data. most i've met don't trust filtered/processed data until they know the methods used to process it, since such processing can easily inject artifacts into the results that aren't present in the original data. using not only an unfamiliar system but one based on alien tech and processing methods? they'd want to see the raw data and do their own analysis.

Avatar
Senior

Whelp, someone has taken root there.

... literally, from the scan.

Now, let's see the non-military ships' equivalent of strolling off sans haste, whistling innocently ...






Share this comic



The author is against any kind of application of AI to his artwork.

TRIVIA
Raharrs are the most numerous species in the Alliance, making up more than half of its total population.